EA Sports Drops NCAA Exclusivity

On a day when the NCAA handed down one of the most unprecedented punishments to Penn State University, I’m surprisingly not going to weigh in with my thoughts.  SImply put, it is disgusting and no matter what the NCAA ruled, it wasn’t enough.  Nothing could be enough.

In news that doesn’t make my blood boil, EA Sports has announced it will not extend the NCAA Football franchise’s exclusive rights when it expires in 2014.  This means that anyone else would be allowed to create an NCAA football game if they acquire the license to make it.

This comes in conjunction with a long standing lawsuit from consumers over the legality of exclusive deals with Madden and the NCAA.  The settlement will pay out a few bucks to those who purchased football games since 2006.  It also means EA Sports cannot sign an exclusive agreement with the Arena Football League, which most people probably weren’t even aware still existed anyway.

The better news for consumers is that the possibility of multiple NCAA Football games will soon exist.  It doesn’t mean EA Sports will discontinue the franchise.  In fact, it is entirely possible they still don’t have competition.  It opens the door for 2K Sports to get back into football however.  It is widely debated that NFL 2k5 remains the greatest football game ever.  In fact, it is said that NFL 2k5 (and its $20 price tag at the time) was the reason EA Sports signed the deal with the NFL.

This game actually existed…and could again.

 

As a longtime NCAA Football fan, this is great news to me.  The game has grown terribly stale.  Defense is still deplorable (and identical to the past five iterations), the AI can’t run or defend the option properly and bugs continue to plague the series at launch each year.  In fact, NCAA 12 was NEVER fixed despite several patches.

NCAA 13 was released recently to a mostly negative reaction from reviewers and fan forums.  Madden has made minor positive strides after a few extremely lackluster years and NCAA fans appear to be fed up with it.  The most enjoyable NCAA I can remember is still on the last generation Xbox.

Knowing the option for improved and alternate NCAA Football games in a couple years is a great feeling.  Now if only SOMEONE would put an NCAA Basketball game on the market.

NCAA Football Rule Changes

The NCAA Football Rules Committee has proposed several rule changes for the 2012 season aimed at increasing player safety.  These are only recommendations, but they will likely come to pass.

  • Kickoff and Touchback Starting Lines Moved. The committee voted to move the kickoff to the 35-yard line (currently set at the 30-yard line), and to require that kicking team players must be no further than five yards from the 35 at the kick, which is intended to limit the running start kicking teams have during the play. The committee also voted to move the touchback distance on free kicks to the 25-yard line instead of the 20-yard line to encourage more touchbacks. NCAA data indicates injuries during kickoffs occur more often than in other phases of the game.
  • Loss of Helmet During Play. If a player loses his helmet (other than as the result of a foul by the opponent, like a facemask), it will be treated like an injury. The player must leave the game and is not allowed to participate for the next play. Current injury timeout rules guard against using this rule to gain an advantage from stopping the clock. Additionally, if a player loses his helmet, he must not continue to participate in play to protect him from injury. Data collected during the 2011 season indicated that helmets came off of players more than two times per game.
  • Blocking Below the Waist. The intent of the changes made last season were to only allow blocking below the waist when the opposing player is likely to be prepared for this contact, but the opposite impact was discovered in some cases. To clarify the intent, the committee approved wording that essentially allows offensive players in the tackle box at the snap that are not in motion to block below the waist legally without restriction. All other players are restricted from blocking below the waist with a few exceptions (e.g. straight ahead blocks).
  • Shield Blocking Scheme on Punting Plays. The committee reviewed several examples of shield blocking, which has become a popular blocking scheme for punting teams. In several cases, a receiving team player attempts to jump over this type of scheme in the backfield to block a punt. In some cases, these players are contacted and end up flipping in the air and landing on their head or shoulders. The committee is extremely concerned about this type of action and proposed a rule similar to the leaping rule on place kicks that does not allow the receiving team to jump over blockers, unless the player jumps straight up or between two players.
  • Additional Protection to Kick Returner. Through officiating interpretation, the committee approved a recommendation to provide a kick returner additional protection to complete a catch before allowing contact by the kicking team.

I find it amusing that they want to move the kickoff line up to the 35 again after just a year ago moving it back to the 30 for some reason.  It should also be noted the NFL went to the 35 in the same year.  This of course will result in more touchbacks, which the NFL saw a ridiculously boring amount of.

Jacquizz Rodgers would be sitting out the next play in 2012.

To compliment the touchback, they want the ball placed on the 25 yard line?  I predict scores will be higher, especially for the best teams in the country.  This is just another step in football to try and eliminate kicking altogether.

I can’t say I understand the helmet loss rule.  This happens occasionally and usually the player is just fine.  According to the article, two helmet losses occurred per game on average….wow.  Why must the entire team suffer because of losing a helmet?

I can’t help but wonder if these head injuries would be less likely if players went back to wearing those old leather helmets.  I’m not sure a player would lead with his head like they do now.

At least the rules committee isn’t worried about fixing important things like the absolutely deplorable and nearly non-existant post-season.